The article critiques Portugal's process for selecting judges of the Constitutional Court, highlighting concerns over political influence and lack of independence. It points out instances where judges have left the Court for political roles or quickly transitioned into government positions, undermining judicial independence. The current appointment system, involving election by the Assembly of the Republic in lists rather than individual nominations, is seen as problematic, as it favors political agreements over merit. Additionally, the minimal educational requirements—only a law degree—allow recently graduated lawyers to become judges, which the author considers inappropriate. Overall, the article advocates for reforms to ensure a more transparent, merit-based, and independent selection process for Constitutional Court judges in Portugal.